Prediction Markets + Market Predictions = Collective Forecasting That Pays Off

Tag Archives: New Hampshire

Flawed New Hampshire polls = Non-accurate New Hampshire prediction markets

The most comprehensive analysis ever conducted of presidential primary polls:
“a handful of methodological missteps and miscalculations combined to undermine the accuracy of predictions about presidential primary winners in New Hampshire and three other states.”
Via Mister the Great Research Scientist David Pennock –who is an indispensable element of the field of prediction markets.

As I blogged many [...]

Ubber finance blogger Barry Ritholtz believes in magic. He believes that, with more volumes on the event derivative markets, comes the Omniscience —capital “O”.

-
Our good friend Barry Ritholtz.has persuaded himself that our real-money prediction markets suffer from an irremediable and fatal problem: liquidity on political event derivative markets is too thin for smart Wall Street people like him to take their market-generated probabilities seriously. Barry Ritholtz is keen to tout oranges–apples comparisons: the NYSE volume versus the Obama–Clinton [...]

Yet another guy, writing about prediction markets in the mainstream media, who does not master what he is talking about.

Via Adam Siegel of Inkling Markets,
John McQuaid of Wired.

It’s incoherent to start a rant against prediction markets by this upbeat line, “Prediction markets can be spookily accurate.”
He blames the New Hampshire upset on poor liquidity. Where is the scientific evidence of that? Total invention by our good friend Barry Ritholtz. The New Hampshire prediction markets [...]

Professor Koleman Strumpf explains the prediction markets to the countryland people.

Ah, Kansas… Barbecues, pickup trucks, rednecks, country music, and… the local FOX News.
Despite that one blip on the radar [New Hampshire], Strumpf said futures are still the best way to predict the way things will go from here.
Spot the SIDEBAR (which is not located on the sidebar, actually), and click on the little square, just [...]

Justin Wolfers on Rudy Giuliani = not convincing… yet

Justin Wolfers investigated the Rudy Giuliani free-fall thru the prism of the InTrade prediction markets in the Wall Street Journal (PDF file).
All told, prediction market data tend to confirm that Mr. Giuliani’s recent decline is due to a poor campaign, rather than a poor strategy.
I have just read the 3-page New York Times story on [...]

Midas Oracle is the only popular, independent, exhaustive, multi-author, multi-exchange, Web-based resource on prediction markets.

Dear Midas Oracle readers,
I’m happy to report progress in building the architecture and content of our group blog, Midas Oracle. Let me introduce you to our 2 master pages: “PREDICTIONS” and “BEST”.


#1. PREDICTIONS

http://www.midasoracle.org/predictions/
= our explainer on prediction markets + the best charts of prediction markets
Following the New Hampshire brouhaha, I believe that the way to [...]

Did the BetFair blog use trading data from InTrade to hint at BetFair’s accuracy??

Latest update on the BetFair blog fiasco

I am alerted today that the BetFair blog has updated its infamous Michigan story with a new compound chart bearing a clearer label. It reads now:
Republican nomination – The race so far
I’ll have some comments, below the chart, but first a technical note. The new chart posted is a [...]

Assessing Probabilistic Predictions 101

Lance Fortnow:
[...] Notice that when we have a surprise victory in a primary, like Clinton in New Hampshire, much of the talk revolves on why the pundits, polls and prediction markets all “failed.” Meanwhile in sports when we see a surprise victory, like the New York Giants over Dallas and then again in Green Bay, [...]

NIALL O’CONNOR ATTACKS THE INTELLECTUAL HONESTY OF THE PREDICTION MARKET RESEARCHERS.

Niall O’Connor (who maybe ate grilled snake for his Sunday morning breakfast ):
The current trend to promote almost illiquid betting markets as being predictive, looks set to backfire bigstyle. In a nutshell, to date the so called “prediction markets” have called it wrong in New Hampshire (Democrats), Michigan (Republicans) and South Carolina (Republicans). [...]

MICHIGAN PRIMARY @ BETFAIR: Niall O’Connor asks the very pertinent question.

UPDATE: I just got it that Professor Leighton Vaughan-Williams’s story and the BetFair compound chart published on top of his story should be understood independently from each other, as this chart was pasted there by the BetFair blog editor.

Let’s re-visit the Michigan primary (BetFair edition) story, now.

Professor Leighton Vaughan-Williams on the official BetFair blog:
[...] Those [...]

Search

Post Categories