Prediction Markets = Collective Forecasting = Collective Intelligence That Predicts

Category Archives: Analysis (Data)

Data Analysis Of The Day — Sex Scandal Edition

Hearthis post

So much for Prof Panos and his data religion

People answer bullshit when polled by Prof Panos and other stats collectors.

Hearthis post

Nate Silver of FiveThirtYeight.com on “The Interview Show” —recorded November 5th, 2008

Nate Silver of fivethirtyeight.com on “The Interview Show,” recorded November 5th, 2008:
-

-
Nate Silver on November 3rd, 2008:

-
Nate Silver on August 21, 2008:
-

Hearthis post

Damped polls outperform prediction markets.

Forecasting Principles:
Damping polls
Evidence from the literature shows that polls, in particular early in the campaign, are not reliable in predicting election outcomes but tend to overestimate the extent to which a candidate leads. To deal with these uncertainties, we added a damping factor to the RCP poll average. Damping is used to make forecasts more [...]

“Guessing all the frontrunners correctly is something to brag ONLY if the reported confidences are high enough.”

“If they are not and you get them all correctly, then the markets have biases and are NOT accurate.”

Hearthis post

Boom and Bust of Prediction Markets

The boom of public and private prediction markets started after the 2004 US elections. InTrade claimed to have nailed “all 50 states”. InTrade’s performance in the 2008 US elections was less stellar, and in line with polls. Hence, the bust we are in.
If true, the good performance of HubDub in the Oscars 2009 forecasting race [...]

Erik Snowberg on the prediction markets about the 2008 US presidential elections

Andy Eggers:
So to sum up, I liked the use of prediction markets to estimate the conditional general election probability for a candidate at a point in time, and I think it’s worth getting some estimates of how particular events moved this probability. I think at this stage the conclusions are a bit underdeveloped and oversold, [...]

A graph with a data point for each state, with the horizontal axis representing the polling data and the vertical axis representing the Intrade contract price

Via Andrew Gelman
On November 3, 2008:

Hearthis post

Prediction markets react to polls.

Learning in Investment Decisions: Evidence from Prediction Markets and Polls – (PDF file) – David S. Lee and Enrico Moretti – 2008-12-XX
In this paper, we explore how polls and prediction markets interact in the context of the 2008 U.S. Presidential election. We begin by presenting some evidence on the relative predictive power of polls and [...]

Emile Servan-Schreiber is such a funny man.

Go to NewsFutures to see this widget.
NewsFutures data on the 2008 US presidential elections —XLS file.

Hearthis post

Search Midas Oracle

Search Midas Oracle

Post Categories