Prediction market blogger quits InTrade.

No Gravatar

Ben Shannon:

New Year Update

Posted by Jesse Livermore on Sunday, January 3, 2010

I&#8217-ve been gone for a while. There just hasn&#8217-t been that much happening on Intrade, and I&#8217-ve been focusing on neuroscience.

Intrade has definitely gotten tougher over the past year. I think the 2008 election drew in a lot of people who weren&#8217-t very good at politics or gambling. By now those people have either lost their money or gotten better. Hopefully the 2010 elections will draw in a new crop.

In the mean time, Intrade&#8217-s management has not done a great job in developing the brand. My impression is that volume is off by more than 50% compared to last year. Chief difficulties:
Absolutely no advertising whatsoever.
Diminished interest in politics in an off-year.
Getting money onto the site requires a lot of determination and a visit to a gas station to buy a Netspend card.

Future updates on this blog will be less-than-daily, basically when I have an opinion about politics that I feel like sharing.

Midas Oracle is the only website in the world to have told you *not* to bet on Chicago -and to stay (far) away from any Olympics venue prediction market.

Previously: Will Chicago get the Olympics? Dona€™t bet on it. Too risky.

6-000-dollars-on-chicago

Had Ben Shannon listened to us, he would have spared $6,000 &#8212-yes, that&#8217-s six thousand US dollars.

burning-money

Next: Could we have divined that Chicago was a lemon?

Why an analyst should assess each newly created prediction market

IOC

The Chicago candidacy, which was favored by the prediction markets (and gullible bettors like Ben Shannon), is the one that fared the worst.

As we have blogged here many times, not every prediction market is created equal. Some are bound to aggregate bits of known information. Some others (e.g., the Olympic city prediction markets) are not able to do that, because no good information is leaking out. The IOC is a close aristocratic group that does not leak out good information. Those who forgot that and bet the farm on Chicago are now licking their wounds. You need an information analyst to assess whether a particular prediction market is pertinent.

– BetFair&#8217-s event derivative prices:

chicago-olympics-betfair

– InTrade&#8217-s event derivative prices:

chicago-olympics-intrade

– HubDub&#8217-s event derivative prices:

Who will recieve the winning bid to host the 2016 Olympics?

Chicago wont have the Olympics in 2016.

IOC

The Chicago candidacy, which was favored by the prediction markets (and bettors like Ben Shannon), is the one that fared the worst.

I TOLD YOU SO:

&#8220-Will Chicago get the Olympics? Dona€™t bet on it. Too risky.&#8220-

The prediction markets are not able to forecast which country will get the Olympics. The IOC is a close aristocratic group that does not leak information. Hence, it is not possible to aggregate information.

Once again, Ben Shannon made a very bad bet. He should read Midas Oracle more often &#8212-if he wants to avoid personal bankruptcy.

– Once again, we see that the P.R. agents of InTrade and BetFair (who both bragged about being able to predict Chicago) were overselling.

BetFair&#8217-s event derivative prices (on the far right of the chart, you can see that the price went down to zero):

chicago-olympics-betfair

InTrade&#8217-s event derivative prices (on the far right of the chart, you can see that the price went down to zero):

chicago-olympics-intrade

– HubDub&#8217-s event derivative prices:

Who will recieve the winning bid to host the 2016 Olympics?

Ben Shannon on his misguided SELL stock market call delivered just before the stock market rally

No Gravatar

Ben Shannon on his &#8220-SELL&#8221- market call

Previously: Wiser Than The Stock Market &#8212- NOT

UPDATE: Andrew Page + Henry Blodget

Share This:

Wiser Than The Stock Market – NOT

No Gravatar

Ben Shannon (alias &#8220-Jesse Livermore&#8221-, who blogs at &#8220-Wiser Than The Crowd&#8221-) claims on his blog to have an uncanny ability at forecasting the future and profiting from it, whether it is speculating on InTrade&#8217-s prediction markets or on the US stock market. Here is his stock market call from July 10, 2009:

SELL SELL SELL

REALITY CHECK:

The stock market is up about 12% since Ben Shannon&#8217-s &#8220-sell sell sell&#8221- call on July 10th.

Spot the 10th on the chart&#8230- Ben Shannon sold the exact bottom immediately before the rally.

ben-shannon-stock-market

Thanks to Deep Throat for the tip.

UPDATE: Ben Shannon on his &#8220-SELL&#8221- market call

Share This: